Are You Staying, Mandy Boyle? is Melanie Moore’s debut novel. Released on November 3, 2026, this Christmas romance takes readers to a small town in Vermont. Mandy Boyle is a 30-something living in her childhood apartment in New York. She’s struggling to find a way forward after giving up her career ten years ago. On an impulse, Mandy enters a contest to become the owner of a newspaper in Vermont. Can she give up everything she knows in the city for a fresh start in a small town?

I want to thank Blackstone Publishing and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an advance copy of Are You Staying, Mandy Boyle? However, all opinions expressed here are solely mine.
Synopsis from Goodreads
Mandy Boyle is thirty-five, still living with her stepfather in his rent-stabilized apartment, and still stuck as a copy editor at The New York Times awaiting the next big layoff. It wasn’t supposed to be like this, but ten years ago she put her journalism career on hold and moved back to the city to care for her dying mother. Of course she can’t be salty about that.
Then everything changes when Mandy wins a 100-plus-year-old newspaper in Vermont, AND the apartment over it—a New Yorker’s dream! The only catch? She must run The Vermont Eagle for one year, and can’t sell it to a conglomerate until that year is up. Sounds great, until Mandy discovers the Eagle is definitely old school, definitely not profitable, and that she is definitely in way over her head.
Suddenly she’s a city girl thrust into a quaint Vermont town at Christmas time where everyone knows everything about each other. One plus? The mechanic in the next building, Greg Stewart, who keeps trying to sell her snow tires and is very easy on the eyes. Mandy would like to know more about him, but he’s plenty guarded. As she struggles to right the sinking newspaper, she bonds with people in the town, including a young woman who is losing her own mother to cancer, an emotional connection that cracks open Mandy’s own guarded heart.
Through it all, Mandy is drawn to Greg. He just may be her best friend. Maybe the love of her life. But how can two such guarded hearts ever fully fall for each other—especially when Mandy is so sure she’ll be leaving by the time next Christmas rolls around?
Positives
- Under 350 pages
- Quick and easy read
- Slow burn romance
- Found family
Negatives
- Did that really have to happen for Ethan to come home?
- Marketing this as a romance.
My Opinions
I added Are You Staying, Mandy Boyle? to my TBR because it sounded like a quirky holiday read. Guess what? It didn’t disappoint either.
Mandy is a 30-something who is trying to figure out who she is and what she wants out of life. She gave up her career path to take care of her mom and lost herself along the way. Mandy is trying to figure out who she is now, as her job no longer gives her the satisfaction she craves. To shake things up, she impulsively enters a contest for a newspaper and finds herself moving from New York City to a small town in Vermont.
The cast is not overly large; a few characters pop in and out, but the core cast consists of around six. The ones that matter the most to the story are easy to keep sorted. But it’s a relatable cast all the same. Mandy is a woman who wants to see the world and make a difference. Greg is a homebody and prefers the small town. Paula is fiercely loyal to those she loves. Nina is the town mom. Lizzy is a ball of energy. Miguel is Mandy’s little brother, and Angel is her stepdad.
Another great thing I loved about the book was the fact that it spans over a year. I was curious how it would work, but I like that Moore took the chance and spread the story out over the year. This gives readers a chance to learn more about Mandy and the rest of the cast — their thoughts, feelings, and motivations.
My biggest issue with the book has nothing to do with the book. It’s with the marketing, and I even mentioned it in my intro. That issue is that Are You Staying, Mandy Boyle? is being marketed as a romance. Hear me out! Yes, I know there is a romance in the book. But it’s not the biggest part of the story. Why not focus on Mandy’s growth and development in the year that we spend with her?
If you enjoy reading books with character growth and development, you should read Are You Staying, Mandy Boyle? The same goes if you enjoy a slow-burn romance that may not be the main focal point of the story.

Are you looking for some more books to read? Check out my bookish lists, book reviews, and monthly reading wrap-ups.
Discover more from Read! Bake! Create!
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

